Wichtiger Beitrag
hawthorneheightfan13

First, i liked the way the point of view changed throughout the story; I imagine that took some thought. I also liked the sense of mystery that emanated from certain parts of the story. Like, you didn't really know who "Sandra Bullock" was...but i guess that doesn't matter, since she was only a small part of the story...The only part that i would work on, was the use of adjectives. Maybe, you could have described what peoples... mehr anzeigen

1 Kommentar
rebekahjennings

Thanks,

Even your eleven year old thoughts are valuable.

Wichtiger Beitrag
lovingempath

...you've broken this up. For me, it was an easy and engrossing read. I like the way you did it, but that's my own opinion. I'm just a beginning writer and have much to learn in the way of formatting. Still...I liked it.
The story itself was told very well. I especially enjoyed your characterizations...the realness of how people's personalities change in the scenes between friends and then a quick switch back to their... mehr anzeigen

Wichtiger Beitrag
scottkelly

I like the writing in this more than the other story - but this one is a little harder to follow. I don't really understand the "Me" and "You" sections and how they are supposed to apply chronologically. I would go back and rewrite this but stick to one person's point of view, or at least pick a "main character." Still, your prose is very good and you write dialogue and describe your characters well.

Wichtiger Beitrag
louisianawytch

I so agree with gooduklady,I liked how it was written. It was easy to follow. I think you did a wonderful job writing this story. I cant wait to read more of your work, Best regards, Rena Kay

Wichtiger Beitrag
joeparente

A bit of confusion on this one.although it started out good i got lost in it in the middle. Still a good story, i will read it again to make sure that I was aware of everything that was going on./joeparente

Wichtiger Beitrag
alysa.s.

Hi Rebekah, I think this story has some interesting elements to it, but I wish you hadn't bothered with changing points of view. I think you seem to be much more in touch with the young girl's voice and situation. It would have been interesting to read the whole thing from her perspective. I also felt that by giving us different points of view, you were setting us up to be suspicious of the main character, as though she'd... mehr anzeigen

Wichtiger Beitrag
gooduklady

Contrary to the other readers' opinions, I liked the way you titled the chapers - Them, Me, etc. It was different and quite easy to follow. I was engrossed by the story. I found it to be well written, easy to read and articulate. The ending was somewhat surprising...as though you had not considered how to finish the story and had just stopped. In any event, you definitely have talent and I did enjoy it. Good luck. I gave yo a vote.

1 Kommentar
rebekahjennings

Thanks for you kind words. I think perhaps I should have thought more about how to resolve the ending. At the time I thought it was right but now I feel perhaps readers will feel like they've come to a dead end and there needed to be a resolution. :)

Wichtiger Beitrag
lshilo

Aside from all of the usual, let me give you some advise writer's, I enjoyed the story. I think experimentation is essential for a writer who is not afraid to rock the status-quot establishment. Structure and correctness can always be learned anytime, creativity takes talent. And you have talent. I'm voting for this one :)
Lee

Wichtiger Beitrag
captflash

Hi Rebekah,
It apprears you've done a bit of experimentation with this story. Instead of scene breaks, (***), you've used "Them," "You," and "Me." There's little difference, with this exception: I found myself wondering what character's head I was in when a scene changed. That's not good because I, the reader, lose my concentration on the story. It's best, at least when you starting out as a writer, to stick to the "First... mehr anzeigen

Wichtiger Beitrag
librarian

Thank you for participating in our short
story writing contest "Family Stories".

The Librarian